oldmanofdoom
Well, It's my first time as a DM and I am running a campaign in Eberron. My players went to Xen'drik and I told them they saw a Tarrasque. I wasn't intending for them to fight it, as I though they would be smart enough to realize that they couldn't possibly win. However, I was wrong. Even though the Tarrasque was there only as part of narrative and a side story, they ran towards it and attacked it. They managed to get away but one of them died. The others revived him a few hours later but he lost all his magic items and other possessions and they're all a bit depressed. Do you think it was my fault? I mean, if you were level 10 and knew that a Tarrasque is 30th, would you go and attack it? And what do you think I should do with that player's character now that he lost all his items? Please, I really don't know what to do.
Comments
First time DM's and the Tarrasque... I tell you...
Wow.
If I was you, oldmanofdoom, I would hold firm to the status quo, and allow them to chalk it up to a lesson well learned. If they aren't more careful, worse things can happen than the loss of a few items.
So some 10th level characters walked into a bar with a Tarrasque...
I agree with Dusk, with one caveat - Are the players truly aware of what a Tarrasque is? If they are, then it makes a poignant statement about their commitment to character - they might have been feeling a bit on-top-of-the-worldish, and this knocked them down quite a few pegs (Almost into the negatives, it sounds like..) If not, I'd be more lenient in cutting them a break. You could magick all of their items back for a fee, or you could make the next adventure something which could allow them to re-equip the disenfranchised character somewhat easily.
The thing to be careful with about unstoppable forces - the Characters ego's seem like immovable objects, and they're always keen to test themselves...
Lesson well learned indeed.
Anyway, thinking patron/benefactor might have some "loaner gear" that is useful but not optimized for that character, and is definitely not perfect replacements. The party would have to leave something of significant value as a deposit for those goods, but then the next thing patron wants them to do would at least re-instate the most useful of the lost items, either by chance or by design ("I'd not thought it worth your attention since you already had something as powerful, but there is rumor of a treasure in the Catacombs...").
Hi, I'm Crap Frankly, Esq.
Someone had to make the joke!
Rase: It's ok, you can't get 'em all.
Learned my lesson! Don't toy with unstoppable forces!